DID TIKTOKKILL COOL?
We have access to more music, fashion, places and culture than any generation before us. So why does everyone suddenly seem to like the same fucking things?
SCROLL TO READ
IN THIS ISSUE
There used to be a minor social currency in knowing something nobody else did.
A band.
A pub.
A clothing brand.
A skate video.
A song you found buried on someone's MySpace page.
Someone would burn you a CD with Track 07 written on it in Sharpie and, because Shazam wasn't sitting in your pocket waiting to solve the mystery, you could spend the next six months having absolutely no idea who made it.
Finding things required a bit of effort.
Or luck.
Or having a cooler older sibling.
Now you can discover a song at 8:03am and by lunchtime you've heard it seventeen times, watched somebody explain its cultural significance, seen three brands use it in an advert and witnessed a 19-year-old declare it over.
We have never had access to this much culture.
And somehow everyone's wearing the same fucking jacket.
What happened?
YOU USED TO HAVE TO GO LOOKING
Discovery used to be inconvenient.
Which might have been the entire point.
You heard a song playing in someone's car and had to ask what it was.
You found a band because someone put them on a mix CD.
You bought a magazine because you liked the person on the cover and accidentally discovered three other things inside it.
You found clothing brands in skate shops.
You heard about pubs from actual human beings.
You watched a skate video because your mate had the DVD.
You downloaded something from LimeWire labelled Linkin_Park_NEW_SONG_FINAL.mp3, discovered it was absolutely not Linkin Park and occasionally found something better.
Taste was built through a strange collection of accidents.
Your older brother.
Your friend's older sister.
Somebody you fancied.
The weird guy at school who somehow knew about every band six months before everyone else.
A magazine.
A forum.
A terrible blog.
The bloke working in the record shop.
You didn't choose all your influences.
You accumulated them.
And because everyone accumulated slightly different ones, people ended up liking slightly different shit.

DISCOVERY USED TO FEEL LIKE DISCOVERY.
THEN THE ALGORITHM GOT REALLY FUCKING GOOD
TikTok is unbelievably good at finding things you'll like.
That's the problem.
Not because algorithms are inherently evil.
Not because we should smash our phones, buy Nokia 3310s and return to a simpler time when accessing the internet required screaming noises from a plastic box in the hallway.
The algorithm is simply very, very good at its job.
It watches.
You stop scrolling.
You watch again.
You send something to a mate.
You search for the brand.
You stay for another four seconds.
And it learns.
Then it gives you more.
Which is brilliant when you've just discovered something genuinely interesting.
But there's a strange side effect when the same machine is doing that for millions of people simultaneously.
Discovery stops feeling like discovery.
It starts feeling like distribution.
A restaurant opens.
TikTok finds it.
Suddenly there's a queue around the block.
A shoe appears.
TikTok finds it.
Suddenly everyone has them.
A forgotten song gets picked up.
TikTok finds it.
Suddenly it's playing underneath a skincare routine, a mountain-bike edit, somebody's divorce announcement and an advert for protein yoghurt.
Something can go from where did you find this? to please make it stop in approximately 72 hours.
That's new.
WE'VE TURNED TASTE INTO CONTENT
There was always performance involved in being cool.
Obviously.
People have been using clothes, music and places to signal who they are since long before anyone uttered the words “For You Page”.
Pretending otherwise would be ridiculous.
Teenagers in 2006 weren't floating around completely unaffected by trends.
We were all copying somebody.
The difference is scale.
Now taste itself is content.
Your outfit is content.
Your bedroom is content.
Your coffee is content.
The book you're reading is content.
The restaurant is content.
The run is content.
The gig is content.
The record collection is content.
Your entire personality can be arranged into a 15-second video with text saying:
things that just make sense.
And once taste becomes content, it becomes measurable.
Views.
Likes.
Saves.
Comments.
Shares.
Which means, consciously or otherwise, we're given constant feedback about whether our taste is the right taste.
That's quite a strange way to develop a personality.
WE USED TO FIND THINGS WE LIKED. NOW THINGS THAT KNOW WE'LL LIKE THEM FIND US.

things that just make sense ↗
THE MICRO-TREND INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX
The internet can now identify, package, name and kill an aesthetic before you've finished deciding whether you like it.
Clean girl.
Mob wife.
Coastal grandmother.
Tomato girl.
Office siren.
Indie sleaze revival.
Whatever we're apparently doing this week.
You can wake up with an outfit you've been wearing for three years and discover somebody has given it a name overnight.
Congratulations.
You're now participating in a trend you didn't know existed.
And because everything needs a label, things stop being individual choices and start becoming categories.
You didn't buy a pair of sunglasses because you liked them.
You're doing X aesthetic.
You didn't decorate your kitchen that way because you found some old stuff you liked.
You're doing Y-core.
You didn't discover an old band.
They're having a revival.
We can't just like anything anymore.
It needs a fucking taxonomy.
Then, once enough people participate, the machine gets bored.
The trend dies.
The wardrobe gets cleared.
And we go looking for the next personality.
DID TIKTOK ACTUALLY KILL COOL?
No.
That would be far too convenient.
TikTok didn't invent trends.
It didn't invent conformity.
It didn't invent people pretending to like something because attractive people like it.
Human beings have been doing that perfectly well by ourselves for centuries.
What changed is the speed.
Culture used to move through scenes.
Cities.
Friend groups.
Magazines.
Shops.
Clubs.
Message boards.
Music venues.
It leaked out.
Now culture can be distributed globally before breakfast.
A teenager in Edinburgh, another in New York and another in Sydney can all discover the same obscure pair of trainers on the same morning.
That's incredible.
It also means obscurity has an increasingly short half-life.
The moment something becomes interesting, the machinery for making everybody aware of it is already running.
Maybe TikTok didn't kill cool.
Maybe it just made cool impossible to keep secret.
THE INTERNET DIDN'T KILL TASTE. IT MADE TASTE INCREDIBLY EASY TO COPY.
MAYBE WE'RE LOOKING FOR COOL IN THE WRONG PLACE
Here's where it gets interesting.
Because if everybody has access to the same references, brands, music, aesthetics and inspiration, then simply knowing about something can't really make you cool anymore.
Anyone can know.
Google exists.
TikTok exists.
Pinterest exists.
You can become reasonably knowledgeable about almost anything before you've finished your morning coffee.
So maybe cool has moved.
Maybe cool isn't knowing about the band first.
Maybe it's still listening to them after everyone else decides they're cringe.
Maybe it's wearing the jacket after TikTok announces the jacket is dead.
Maybe it's going to the same pub even though nobody photographs it.
Maybe it's riding a bike nobody is sponsoring you to ride.
Maybe it's running without uploading the run.
Maybe it's making something that gets 14 likes.
Maybe it's spending six months learning something you're absolutely shit at.
Maybe it's refusing to abandon something you genuinely love just because the internet has collectively moved on.
Because trends aren't actually the problem.
Needing trends to tell you what you like is.

WOULD YOU STILL DO IT IF NOBODY SAW IT?
That's probably the test.
Take away the camera.
Take away the Strava upload.
Take away the Instagram Story.
Take away the audience.
Take away the possibility that somebody might think you're interesting because of it.
Would you still go?
Would you still wear it?
Would you still listen to it?
Would you still build it?
Would you still ride it?
Would you still make it?
Would you still spend an unreasonable amount of money on it?
Would you still care?
If the answer is yes, you've probably found something worth keeping.
COOL IS GIVING ENOUGH OF A SHIT ABOUT SOMETHING THAT YOU'D STILL DO IT IF NOBODY SAW IT.
And maybe that's why the people who actually seem cool rarely appear particularly concerned with proving it.
They're busy.
They're in garages.
They're at tiny gigs.
They're halfway up hills.
They're making terrible art.
They're rebuilding things.
They're trying something again.
They're wearing something because they've owned it for ten years and still like it.
They're doing the thing rather than filming themselves explaining that they're the sort of person who does the thing.
STOP TRYING TO BE INTERESTING
The irony is that we've never had more tools for expressing individuality.
You can find practically any music ever recorded.
Buy clothes from almost anywhere.
Learn obscure skills.
Find tiny communities.
Watch films from another side of the world.
Read independent magazines.
Discover artists with 200 followers.
Find somebody making something incredible in a shed in Fife.
The internet hasn't removed individuality.
If anything, it has handed us an absurd amount of material to build one.
We just have to occasionally leave the algorithm's recommendations.
Click page four.
Go into the weird shop.
Watch the video with 312 views.
Listen to your mate's terrible band.
Talk to somebody.
Buy the magazine.
Go to the tiny gig.
Take the wrong turn.
Let something find you accidentally.
And when you find something you genuinely love?
Maybe don't immediately ask whether it's cool.

THE LAST WORD
Did TikTok kill cool?
Probably not.
But it did make it much easier for all of us to look exactly like we're cool.
And those aren't quite the same thing.
Cool was never really the jacket.
Or the band.
Or the bar.
Or knowing about something three months before everybody else.
It was giving enough of a shit about something that you'd still be there after everyone else left.
KEEP THE WEIRD STUFF.
TUESDAY CLUB.



SEND THIS TO SOMEONE WHO STILL HAS THEIR OWN TASTE.